News Spotlight Briefing More Spotlights

North Korea hunger

Updated: Tue, 23 Apr 2013

Secret hungerBack to top

Millions of North Koreans experience chronic food shortages, which have had a dramatic impact on their health and wellbeing, says the World Food Programme (WFP).

The mountainous country cannot produce enough food to feed its people because it lacks agricultural land, high-quality seeds, fuel, fertiliser, and even decent storage facilities, says Human Rights Watch. Floods and droughts often make matters worse.

During the annual April-October "lean season" before the autumn harvests, many North Koreans are forced to eat fewer and smaller meals and gather wild foods. Urban residents often rely on remittances from friends and relatives in rural areas, who generally have better access to food.

The country's northeast has the worst food shortages, according to FAO.

Humanitarian aid – which includes food and much-needed fertilisers – is limited by donor fatigue, and international sanctions have shrunk the country's foreign exchange earnings and affected its ability to buy food from overseas. A disastrous currency reform in November 2009 wiped out ordinary people's savings, triggered spiralling inflation and led to a further drop in food imports.

The country's public distribution system was the main source of food for most North Koreans until the system broke down during the famine in the mid-1990s. Gradually the regime allowed a limited form of commercial trading to develop and the majority – bar high-ranking officials who receive full food rations – began to rely on markets to survive.

But in 2005 the state began to clamp down on the market system, and reimposed its control over the population by reverting to the public distribution system which was in fact unable to meet people's needs. The botched currency reform in 2009 was aimed at cutting into the power of the burgeoning merchant class. It prompted rare social unrest.

"What should not be forgotten, however, is that the country is not poor ... the resources of the country are misspent, misallocated and misused on the elite and the 'military first' policy to the detriment of the populace. Such is the injustice – latent, patent and blatant," the former U.N. Special Rapporteur on human rights in North Korea, Vitit Muntarbhorn, said in February 2010.

The country's healthcare has also deteriorated since the 1990s. North Korea has no shortage of doctors and nurses, but drugs, equipment and even antiseptics are in short supply or non-existent. Many people do not have access to clean water, according to the 2012 survey carried out by Korean authorities and U.N. agencies.

Delivering aid in a secretive stateBack to top

The world has committed billions of dollars in food aid, but comprehensive aid programmes have been hampered by government obstruction and international fears over North Korea's nuclear ambitions.

A critical issue has been the restrictions the North places on aid workers' ability to check where the food ends up. WFP donors say monitoring is vital to ensure that aid is not diverted to the military or the ruling party which has been accused of appalling human rights abuses.

WFP has a principle of "no access-no food" and international staff monitor distribution. But aid workers have to obtain official permission to access areas and are often obliged to use local interpreters. However, WFP was allowed to use interpreters of any nationality in its emergency operation launched in April 2011, and its staff were given unprecedented access to vulnerable regions to oversee WFP’s operations.

North Korea has also relied heavily on bilateral aid from China and South Korea, which do not insist on monitoring.

But the South turned off the tap in 2008 with a new government saying its future generosity would depend on Pyongyang's progress in abiding by an international nuclear pact and other political issues.

In 2008, the United States pledged to give 500,000 tonnes of food aid to North Korea – its first bilateral assistance in eight years. The bulk of it was to be distributed through the WFP, and 100,000 tonnes of food through five U.S. non-governmental organisations (NGOs). Distribution began in July after North Korea agreed to relax restrictions on aid agencies' ability to monitor deliveries in an unprecedented deal. But this was stalled by the North Korean government in 2009, and the NGOs distributing the food were thrown out of the country.

In 2010, former U.N. Special Rapporteur Muntarbhorn said this may have been because the government rejected closer international monitoring of aid procedures and because of fears the aid groups might start using Korean-speaking interpreters from outside the country.

Pyongyang has since reached out to dozens of countries and organisations around the world for aid, complaining that bad weather, rising global food prices and the termination of aid had slashed supplies.

In March 2011, the United Nations estimated that more than 6 million people needed food aid, , and a third of children were chronically malnourished or 'stunted'.

In May, South Korea said it suspected Pyongyang of exaggerating the food crisis and of trying to hoard food ahead of a nuclear test, which would likely provoke a tightening of international sanctions. Some South Korean officials also said the North might be trying to stockpile food to give away as part of the 2012 celebrations to mark the centenary of the birth of the state's founder, Kim Il-sung.

In July, the European Commission said it was convinced that the North's pleas for help were genuine and announced an aid package aimed at severely malnourished children under five years old who had already been hospitalised.

In 2012, North Korea asked the United Nations for urgent food aid after devastating floods in July.

A survey carried out by the government and U.N. agencies in late 2012, found that nearly 28 percent of children under the age of five were chronically malnourished.

Chronic food insecurity affects two-thirds of the country's 24 million people, the Assessment Capacities Project said in April 2013.

And an estimated 2.8 million people face severe hunger and need international food aid, most of them in the northeast provinces of the country, an April 2013 report by the United Nations’ Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) said.

But reluctance by donors continue to hamper WFP’s operations in the country. Its emergency food aid operation that ran from April 2011 to June 2012 was only 30 percent funded.

The road to famineBack to top

In the 1990s North Korea suffered one of the most destructive famines of the 20th century. No one knows how many people died, although analysts say it killed at least 1 million people, and between 3 and 5 percent of the population.

Since then the country has been heavily reliant on international food aid.

So how did the country end up in this mess?

Pyongyang points the finger at a series of natural catastrophes but this is not the whole story.

After World War Two the Korean peninsula split in two. The U.S.-backed Republic of Korea proclaimed sovereignty in the South and the Soviet-backed Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) did the same in the North.

The North invaded the South in 1950 hoping to unify the peninsula. The conflict ended with an armistice in 1953. Since then South Korea has grown into one of Asia's most affluent countries, while the North has slid into poverty.

Before the split, the southern part of the Korean peninsula was the traditional rice basket for the whole country. After the split, the Communist north collectivised agriculture and set up a public distribution system to distribute food according to age, occupation, region, and political loyalty. This was an important means of political control and the main source of food for most North Koreans until the system broke down during the famine in the mid-1990s.

The man who shaped North Korea was its founding father and "eternal president" Kim Il-sung who introduced a philosophy of juche, or self-reliance. But this strategy has caused major problems given that only a fifth of the land is arable and the climate is less than favourable.

Despite its commitment to self-sufficiency, North Korea actually relied heavily on its socialist allies for products including fertiliser and insecticides. With the collapse of the Soviet Union it found itself in dire straits.

Although China continued to supply petroleum and food, this was no match for the help once received from the Soviet Union. And China itself was changing and increasingly wanted hard currency for its exports.

As outside assistance fell, so did government rations via the public distribution system and the annual farm workers' grain allowance. In 1991, the government initiated a "Let's eat two meals a day" campaign.

Kim Il-sung died in 1994 and was succeeded by his son, Kim Jong-il, referred to as "Dear Leader" in state media. The succession marked the only time in history that rule of a communist state has passed from a father to a son.

Death rates in North Korea were rising by 1994, if not earlier, and by the spring of 1995 the situation had grown desperate enough for Pyongyang to ask Japan and South Korea for emergency assistance. But things were about to get worse.

In the summer of 1995 the country was hit by floods. The effects were exacerbated by soil erosion and river silting caused by previous deforestation that was the result of North Korea's efforts to increase cultivation. There were more floods in 1996.

But as aid began arriving in North Korea, the country took the curious step of reducing its commercial imports, diverting the money it saved to other priorities including the military, according to the Hunger and human rights in North Korea report by the U.S. Committee for Human Rights in North Korea.

In 1999, at the same time as North Korea was cutting grain imports, it spent scarce foreign exchange on 40 MiG-21 fighters and eight military helicopters from Kazakhstan, the report's authors say.

"Times would have been tough under almost any policy, but a famine killing 3-5 percent of the population was not pre-ordained," they add.

LinksBack to top

North Korea is the world's most secretive country. Since 1995 the World Food Programme has acted as a rare window on North Korea.

A few other aid agencies run low-key programmes in North Korea, including: Mercy Corps, Global Resource Services and Christian Friends of Korea.

For a comprehensive overview of the reasons behind the 1990s famine have a look at Hunger and human rights in North Korea: The politics of famine in North Korea by the Committee for Human Rights in North Korea. It also has other useful reports on North Korea.

"Famine and Reform in North Korea", a 2003 report by Marcus Noland of the Institute for International Economics, contains much the same information as "Hunger and Human Rights" (which he co-wrote) but it is useful for an in-depth analysis of the different death toll estimates.

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees has information about North Koreans who have fled hunger and oppression.

For human rights information on North Korea, visit UNHCR website Refworld and Human Rights Watch.

North Korea's state-run Korean Central News Agency is worth a look for news from the regime's perspective.

TimelineBack to top

1945 - Independence from Japan

1948 - Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) formally established

1950 - North Korea invades South Korea

1953 - Korean war ends in an armistice

1987 - Government food rations reduced following first cut in Soviet assistance

1991 - DPRK initiates a "Let's eat two meals a day" campaign

1994 - Kim Il-sung dies. Mortality rates are on the rise. Severe hailstorms

1995 - As food shortages worsen the DPRK asks for help from Japan and South Korea. First shipment leaves for DPRK in June. WFP begins operations in North Korea

Jul-Aug - Severe floods. DPRK says a fifth of the population is affected

Oct - DPRK signs a framework agreement with the U.S. to freeze its nuclear programme in exchange for two light-water nuclear reactors

1996 - Severe floods. Some 16 percent of arable land is destroyed in 1995-1996

1997 - Drought hits fertile west coast June to August

1998 - Kim Il-sung declared Eternal President

Aug - U.S. congressional team says famine has killed 300,000 to 800,000 people a year in the past three years. U.N. food brought in to help famine victims

1998 - Kim Jong-il named head of state

2000 - The leaders of North and South Korea meet for first time in Pyongyang. Drought and serious tropical storms strike

2001 - DPRK says has worst spring drought in its history

2002 - Piecemeal economic reforms. Unemployment rises, as do prices of staple foods

2003

Jan - North Korea withdraws from Nuclear Non Proliferation Treaty aimed at preventing spread of atomic weapons. American officials say North Korea has told the United States it has nuclear weapons and might test them or transfer them to other countries

2004 - DPRK cereal rations are 200-250g - half the recommended daily amount

2005

Aug - DPRK asks WFP to switch from humanitarian assistance to long-term development programmes

Sep - DPRK signs agreement to scrap its nuclear programmes in exchange for aid, security assurances and greater diplomatic recognition

Oct - Cereal rations raised to 500g per person per day

Nov - 19 food factories established by WFP are closed down

Dec - WFP pulls out amid disagreements over monitoring of future aid

2006

May - WFP signs agreement with DPRK, paving the way for a two-year plan to help 1.9 million people

Jul - DPRK defies international warnings and test-fires seven missiles. The country is hit by major storms, causing floods that kill hundreds and displace tens of thousands

Aug - DPRK initially turns down offers of aid, but later accepts humanitarian assistance from South Korean Red Cross and WFP. The South Korean government suspends regular rice aid in protest at the missile tests

Oct - North Korea says it has carried out a nuclear test, prompting condemnation from around the world, including key aid supplier China

U.N. Security Council votes unanimously in favour of imposing sanctions in response to the nuclear test. International funding for relief programmes drops sharply, despite the fact the sanctions exclude humanitarian aid

Nov - Analysts and aid workers warn that North Korea is slipping back into a famine that could trigger a mass exodus of refugees

Dec - U.N. agencies issue dire warnings for North Korea. They report that summer floods decimated domestic food production, placing an already vulnerable population at risk of rising malnutrition during the harsh winter months

2007

Feb - Six-nation talks in Beijing yield an agreement from Pyongyang to take steps towards nuclear disarmament in exchange for energy aid

Mar - Seoul announces it plans to resume fertiliser shipments to the North in time for spring sowing

North Korea admits to food shortages of a million tonnes. WFP warns millions of people are vulnerable to hunger in the absence of better donor support

Aug - U.N. appeals for $15 million to deal with the aftermath of severe flooding, which it says killed more than 450 people and affected over 960,000

Oct - Leaders of the two Koreas hold second summit. They agree to seek talks with China and the United States for a peace treaty

Nov - Prime ministers from both Koreas meet for first time in 15 years to discuss details of massive aid package to help rebuild impoverished North's infrastructure

Dec - The two Koreas start their first regular train service since the 1950-1953 war

2008

Early 2008 - New South Korean government ties aid to Pyongyang's progress in nuclear disarmament

Apr - WFP says North Korea experiencing acute food shortages

May - United States announces 500,000 tonnes of food aid

Jul - WFP expands operations, and warns country is experiencing its worst food shortages since 1990s famine. WFP and five aid agencies start overseeing delivery of U.S. aid after North Korea eases restrictions on their ability to monitor distribution

Aug - Kim Jong-il suffers a stroke

2009

Mar - United States says North Korea has refused any more U.S. food aid supplies, and thrown out five aid groups

Apr - North Korea walks out of six-nation talks on its nuclear programme, after U.N. Security Council criticises its launch of a rocket carrying what North Korea describes as a communications satellite. Parliament re-elects Kim Jong-il as leader

May - North Korea carries out underground nuclear test

North Korea says it is no longer bound by the terms of 1953 armistice

Jun - U.N. Security Council imposes tougher sanctions on North Korea

Oct - U.N. envoy describes human rights in North Korea as "abysmal"

Nov - Currency reform wipes out people's savings, worsens food shortages, causes spiralling inflation and triggers public protests

2010

Feb - Reports emerge that government has eased restrictions on private markets

May - Investigators say North Korea sank South Korean warship in March

Sep - United States imposes new sanctions in response to sinking of South Korean warship

Two months of floods destroy crops. South Korea sends rice aid to North for first time in three years

Kim Jong-il gives his youngest son Kim Jong-un his first public title, naming him a general what analysts say is the first stage of dynastic succession

Oct - Kim Jong-un confirmed as heir apparent

Nov – Pyongyang discloses a uranium enrichment facility with potential to produce nuclear weapons, claiming it is for civilian nuclear power. ; Seoul turns down Pyongyang's requests for food and fertiliser aid

2011

Feb – Foot and mouth disease threatens to worsen food crisis

Mar – United Nations says more than 6 million people are in urgent need of food aid

Apr - Former U.S. President Jimmy Carter visits North Korea and says withholding food aid is a human rights violation. WFP launches emergency operation to reach 3.5 million

May - U.S. special envoy for human rights, Robert King, leads a U.S. team to North Korea to assess its pleas for food

Jul – EU announces aid package targeting severely malnourished young children, saying over half a million people at risk of dying

Dec - Kim Jong-il dies of a heart attack at the age of 69, and is succeeded by his youngest son Kim Jong-un

2012

Aug - Floods, that began in July and were followed by a typhoon, affect an estimated 700,000 people. The United Nations says North Korea is urgently seeking food aid

2013

Feb - North Korea carries out a third nuclear test

Mar - U.N. Security Council approves fresh sanctions against North Korea in response to nuclear test

U.S. and South Korea begin annual joint military exercises

Apr - North Korea warns foreigners to leave the region to avoid the threat of war

North Korea asks Mongolia for food aid

TOP SPOTLIGHT
NEWS IN PICTURES
The sun rises as small-particle haze hangs above the skyline in Paris
A woman holds up a sign during the annual March of Resistance in Buenos Aires
A farmer checks the state of his rapeseed flowers
Displaced Iraqis who fled the Islamic State stronghold of Mosul wait to fill fuel used for cooking and lighting, at...
TOP SLIDESHOW
LATEST SPOTLIGHTS