Our award-winning reporting has moved

Context provides news and analysis on three of the world’s most critical issues:

climate change, the impact of technology on society, and inclusive economies.

Scaffolding firm says workers smoked at Paris' Notre-Dame

by Reuters
Wednesday, 24 April 2019 19:01 GMT

* Police confirms cigarette butts were found in cathedral

* Scaffolding firm says lifts were well maintained

* Church says electric wiring was properly installed

By Julie Carriat and Emmanuel Jarry

PARIS, April 24 (Reuters) - A scaffolding firm that has worked on the roof of Notre-Dame said some of its workers had smoked on the site, but ruled out that a cigarette butt might have started the fire that destroyed the cathedral's oak-framed roof last week.

A spokesman for family-owned Le Bras Freres, confirming a report in French weekly Le Canard Enchaine, told Reuters that some workers of its Europe Echafaudage scaffolding unit had informed police that they had "sometimes" smoked on the scaffolding, despite a smoking ban on the site.

"We condemn it. But the fire started inside the building... so for company Le Bras this is not a hypothesis, it was not a cigarette butt that set Notre-Dame de Paris on fire," Le Bras Frères spokesman Marc Eskenazi said.

The Canard Enchaine reported that police had found the remains of seven cigarette butts in the burnt-out cathedral.

"This is not wrong," said a source close to the investigation, who declined all other comment.

Eskenazi said it was impossible to set a log on fire with a cigarette butt and questioned how cigarette butts could have been found on the site.

"If cigarette butts have survived the inferno, I do not know what material they were made of," he said.

Europe Echaffaudage also ruled out the possibility that the fire might have been started by an electricity incident at one of the two lifts on the site.

"The lifts' electricity was perfectly within specifications and well maintained," he said.

He added that the two lifts were on the outside of the building, situated at 45 and 65 metres (71 yards) from the base of the spire, where the first smoke and flames had been spotted and that the workers had cut the power to the lifts at 1750 when they had left the site for the day.

The Canard Enchaine also reported that electrical wiring ran through the roof of the cathedral, but the church administration denied that safety norms had not been respected.

"Nothing was ever done without the authorisation of the state...There were no wires dangling, everything was properly installed," Notre-Dame spokesman Andre Finot said.

In 2012, electrical engines had been installed to sound the bells in the spire.

Finot said that when a first smoke alarm rang, security staff had made verifications but had not remarked anything unusual.

"I don't know whether they might have checked the wrong place," he said. He added that when a second alert rang shortly after, they spotted flames at the base of the fire.

The Paris prosecutor's office said that it is not ruling out any hypothesis about the origin of the fire and that investigators are considering all possibilities.

President Emmanuel Macron has pledged that Notre-Dame will be rebuilt within five years.

The cathedral was built over nearly 200 years starting in the middle of the 12th century, but the spire on its roof was added during a 19th century restoration. (Reporting Julie Carriat and Emmanuel Jarry Writing by Geert De Clercq; Editing by Angus MacSwan)

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.