Malaysian mothers win lawsuit in 'sexist' citizenship case

by Emma Batha | @emmabatha | Thomson Reuters Foundation
Thursday, 9 September 2021 15:49 GMT

Choong Wai Li and her son Michael are pictured in Hong Kong in 2019. Photo supplied by Choong Wai Li

Image Caption and Rights Information

The landmark ruling allows Malaysian women to pass their nationality to children born overseas

By Emma Batha

Sept 9 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - A group of Malaysian mothers won a legal battle on Thursday for the right to pass their nationality to children born overseas - a landmark ruling that campaigners said could spur efforts to reform discriminatory citizenship laws in other countries.

Malaysia allows men to confer citizenship to children born abroad, but women have been denied the same right as the constitution only refers to the "father" passing on his nationality.

Malaysian mothers fight government over 'sexist' citizenship law

In a lawsuit filed at the High Court, six mothers and campaign group Family Frontiers argued that the provision violated Article 8 of the constitution which bans gender discrimination.

The High Court ruled on Thursday that the word "father" must be read to include mothers, and said their overseas-born children were entitled to Malaysian citizenship.

"I'm so thrilled. It's a big win," one of the mothers - former squash champion Choong Wai Li - told the Thomson Reuters Foundation by phone. Choong said that she had dressed her 7-year-old son in a T-shirt with the Malaysian flag to celebrate.

Like the other mothers in the case, Choong is married to a foreign national and gave birth abroad. The women said the citizenship rules split up families, risked trapping women in abusive relationships, and could leave children stateless.

The government - which has previously described the case as "frivolous" - did not respond to a request for comment, but is expected to appeal the court ruling, according to campaigners.

Choong Wai Li's son wears his Malaysia T-shirt and gives a thumbs up after the High Court rules he is entitled to Malaysian citizenship. Picture provided by Choong Wai Li, Sept 9, 2021

It is unknown how many women in Malaysia have been affected by the issue, but Family Frontiers said the number of binational families was rising as more people spent time working abroad.

Twenty-four countries do not give mothers and fathers equal rights to pass their nationality to their children, and activists said the legal victory could drive change.

"This decision only increases the momentum for equal nationality laws around the world," said Catherine Harrington of the Global Campaign for Equal Nationality Rights.

"We believe other governments will be encouraged by this decision to enact these needed reforms and urge them to do so without delay."

RIGHTS DENIED

Family Frontiers said mothers returning to Malaysia after giving birth abroad faced problems accessing residency, education, healthcare and social services for their children.

Lawyers said the coronavirus pandemic had highlighted the issue, with some women unable to return home due to entry restrictions on foreign nationals - including their children.

Family Frontiers said the ruling was a "momentous decision" and "a huge relief" for affected mothers.

"This judgement recognises Malaysian women's equality, and marks one step forward to a more egalitarian and just Malaysia," said the group's president Suri Kempe.

Another mother in the case - bank executive Myra Silwizya - said she had battled for years to get citizenship for her 8-year-old daughter, who was born in Zambia.

"I am so happy and I cannot wait to tell her that she is also Malaysian, just like her brother," she said.

Myra Silwizya pictured with her husband and family. Picture provided by Family Frontiers.

Non-Malaysian children do not have the same rights to healthcare and education as Malaysian children, meaning their parents face additional costs for schooling, health insurance and visas.

This often deters women from returning home after giving birth to raise their families, as does the fear that their children will have to leave the country once they are adults.

Six nations, including Barbados, Iraq and Liberia, have similar rules to those in Malaysia, while another 18 - among them Nepal, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia - do not let mothers confer citizenship to children even if they were born in the country.

The Global Campaign for Equal Nationality Rights said there was growing momentum to address the issue with more than 20 countries having amended discriminatory citizenship laws since 2003, but added that reforms were often partial.

Related stories:

Nepalese mum tells how unfair citizenship laws squander children's futures

Egyptian women oppose 'repressive' bill to strip them of rights and freedoms

From Syria to COVID-19 frontline, stateless scientist sets sights on vaccine

(Reporting by Emma Batha in London @emmabatha; Editing by Kieran Guilbert. Please credit the Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, which covers the lives of people around the world who struggle to live freely or fairly. Visit http://news.trust.org)

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.