Brazil jobs program puts migrants at risk of abuse, official warns

by Fabio Teixeira | @ffctt | Thomson Reuters Foundation
Wednesday, 6 July 2022 09:00 GMT

A Venezuelan migrant carrying a baby walks along a trail into Brazil, in the border city of Pacaraima, Brazil, April 11, 2019. Picture taken April 11, 2019. REUTERS/Pilar Olivares

Image Caption and Rights Information

Venezuelan migrants worked in slavery-like conditions on a Sao Paulo orange farm after finding the jobs through Operation Welcome

By Fabio Teixeira

RIO DE JANEIRO, July 5 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - A Brazilian labor inspector has denounced failings in a government program that matches migrants with job vacancies after assisting 12 Venezuelans who worked in slavery-like conditions on an orange plantation in the south of the country.

The ordeal of the dozen workers, who had been forced to return their meager wages to pay for food, is the latest exploitation case involving migrants placed in jobs by Operation Welcome, a federal program supporting migrants from Venezuela.

One of the labor inspectors who aided the 12 migrants after they fled the citrus farm in Sao Paulo state last month told the Thomson Reuters Foundation the case reflected inadequate vetting of employers by Operation Welcome officials.

"The resettlement is being done ... without any care," said Paulo Roberto Warlet, the coordinator of the federal government's anti-slavery operations in Sao Paulo, adding that such shortcomings exposed migrants to potential labor abuses.

He said that a lack of proper employer checks made the government "complicit" in human trafficking.

"It cannot be accepted that the Union, under the guise of a humanitarian initiative ... be co-author or participant in illicit trafficking in persons," said Warlet's preliminary report on last month's incident.

The agency that oversees Operation Welcome - the Federal Committee for Emergency Assistance (CFAE) - said it had carried out checks into the company the migrants' employer told them he represented, and had required him to sign a statement saying he did not engage in slave labor.

"The entire interiorization process is under constant evaluation for appropriate and necessary improvements and changes," the CFAE said in a written statement.

Following the workers' escape and subsequent complaint, the owner of the orange plantation agreed to pay them 5,000 reais ($940) each in damages.

Operation Welcome, called Operacao Acolhida in Portuguese, is led by Brazil's military, with help from nonprofits, the private sector and U.N. agencies.

Venezuelan migrants walk along a trail into Brazil, in the border city of Pacaraima, Brazil, April 11, 2019. Picture taken April 11, 2019. REUTERS/Pilar Olivares

The criticism leveled at the program by Warlet echoes concerns voiced a year ago by state officials, academics and labor officials, who questioned the lack of a system to vet companies or audit them after they hire Venezuelans.

They spoke after being presented with the findings of a Thomson Reuters Foundation investigation that analyzed six cases of suspected exploitation or slave labor involving Venezuelans hired by companies via Operation Welcome's resettlement program.

According to Warlet's report, the Venezuelans arrived in Sao Paulo having been promised a monthly salary of 1,500 reais, slightly above the minimum wage of 1,212 reais, plus free housing and transportation to work.

But they each got paid just 50 reais for the 15 days of work they put in before they fled, and were forced to return it to their employer - ostensibly so food could be bought for them.

The migrants had received debit cards from a non-profit linked to Operation Welcome, the Labor Ministry said. But the cards were seized by the employer when they arrived at the farm, leaving the workers penniless, Warlet's report said.

The company name provided by the employer turned out to be false, the report added.

Warlet said he feared Venezuelans across Brazil could be at risk of similar exploitation due to a lack of proper scrutiny of would-be employers.

"They are people in absolute vulnerability who are having their rights debased by the Brazilian state," said Warlet, who has sent a copy of his report to the CFAE as well as federal prosecutors.

This article was updated on July 7 to clarify that a non-profit provided debit cards to migrants  after the Labor Ministry provided details.

Related stories:

U.S. law to ban goods using Uyghur forced labor is just the start

Thailand bars prisons from using inmates to make fishing nets

Brazil's charcoal industry fuels illegal deforestation and slavery

($1 = 5.3216 reais)

(Reporting by Fabio Teixeira @ffctt; Editing by Helen Popper. Please credit the Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers the lives of people around the world who struggle to live freely or fairly. Visit

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.