People continue to die in Indian mines four years after a Thomson Reuters Foundation expose into child deaths
By Roli Srivastava
MUMBAI, India, Jan 6 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - When India went into lockdown last March and Tota Rai lost his cleaning job in the textile hub of Surat, he knew working in the illegal mica mining industry back home was his only option.
Rai, 45, and his three sons - two adults and one teenager - now spend their days scavenging for scraps of the valued mineral used to put the sparkle into make-up and car paint and in electronics to sell to local traders in eastern Jharkhand state.
But as the pandemic drives more families to mica, residents, researchers and campaigners have voiced concerns over failings by the government and private sector to regulate the often fatal trade sourced from abandoned mines and to create other jobs.
A Thomson Reuters Foundation expose in 2016 found children dying in derelict mines in three states with families paid "blood money" to stay silent, prompting vows by brands to clean up supply chains and authorities to legalize and regulate mica.
Rai said his job as a hostel cleaner paid 5,000 rupees ($68) monthly but now he was fortunate to make 50 rupees a day selling mica gathered outside mines shuttered in the 1980s amid laws to limit deforestation and as alternatives to natural mica emerged.
"I reached home with great difficulty but there was no other work here," said Rai, who cycled 2,000 km (1,240 miles) over 10 days to return to his village in Giridih, joining the ranks of millions of workers who headed home when COVID-19 struck India.
"Mica is our only hope to survive ... I just want to be allowed to pick mica," he said by phone from his mud hut in a region where even the roadside soil glitters with the mineral.
Jharkhand's state government said action was underway to legalize the sector but progress had been slower than hoped.
K. Srinivasan, secretary in the Department of Mines and Geology, said a new policy was in the pipeline to "initiate mica mining legally in Jharkhand" and ensure jobs.
"We genuinely want to solve the problem," he said.
India is one of the world's top producers of mica.
Once boasting more than 700 mines with over 20,000 workers, the industry was hit by 1980s legislation to limit deforestation and the discovery of substitutes for natural mica - forcing most mines to close due to cost and stringent environmental rules.
But renewed interest in mica from China's economic boom and a global craze for natural cosmetics saw illegal operators reopen abandoned mines in recent years, creating a lucrative black market but sometimes with tragic results.
Despite the dangers, Rai said there was no choice but to pick mica with no other work.
After returning home in August, he joined a mica workers' collective set up by local officials to help people find work through state schemes but only secured eight days work in four months, and his pay was delayed - which drove him back to mica.
"There is nothing here except mica ... all the children in my village go to collect mica," he said.
A follow-up investigation by the Thomson Reuters Foundation in 2019 found adults and children were still dying in the mines, with the global attention making people less likely to report deaths for fear of arrest or losing their earnings.
Traders and campaigners in two mica hubs in Jharkhand - Giridih and Koderma - estimate that thousands of people last year joined the ranks of 50,000-odd mica miners and pickers due to job losses and school closures caused by the pandemic.
"People at the lowest level of the mica supply chain are children and the poorest of the poor, often with no land holding," said Bhuwan Ribhu, a child rights activist who has worked for years with mica-dependent communities in Jharkhand.
"Their debts have increased (due to COVID-19) and we are worried that it might lead to a bonded labour situation," he added, referring to people taking out loans from money lenders at high interest rates, a practice known to fuel modern slavery.
"TOOTHLESS" MEASURES
Activists and academics said the pandemic had exposed the slow pace and limited scope of promised reforms by the Jharkhand government and the Responsible Mica Initiative (RMI), set up in 2016 to end child labour and improve conditions in mica mines.
Both the government and the RMI have been criticised for focusing on modest community-level measures at the expense of pushing to legalise the sector and create alternative jobs.
"The policies (of the RMI and Jharkhand government) were limited to withdrawing children from mines," said Professor Sanjai Bhatt of Delhi School of Social Work, who has researched mica-dependency in villages in Jharkhand over the last decade.
"Livelihood was seen as a separate problem. There was no connection," he added. "The RMI is a good but toothless initiative in that regard ... of bringing about a policy change. And the government says it has offered jobs, but how many?"
The RMI, whose 60-odd members include cosmetics firm L'Oréal and drugs and chemical group Merck KGaA, raised about 880,000 euros ($1.1 million) last year - down 30,000 euros on 2019 - to fund projects in dozens of villages across India's mica belt.
The Paris-based coalition said it has put hundreds of children back in schools and helped families to find other sources of income and get connected to state welfare schemes.
"It's a shared responsibility," said RMI head Fanny Fremont, adding that governments, charities and corporates together needed to "implement solutions with long-lasting impacts".
The Thomson Reuters Foundation questioned several RMI brands such as L'Oréal, Merck KGaA, and new 2020 member Porsche about mica mining in Jharkhand and their own financial contributions.
L'Oreal and Merck said they were aware of unsafe conditions and the risk of child labour but continued to source Indian mica so as not to "further weaken the situation in the region".
Porsche, a subsidiary of Germany's biggest carmaker Volkswagen, did not respond to request for comment.
The RMI last year announced a sustainable mica mining policy that aimed to create jobs for 210,000 workers in Jharkhand and boost exports from 2021, but two state government officials said the plan was not feasible while the industry was still illegal.
Srinivasan said regulating the industry required investment from the private sector and past attempts to sell mica blocks to mining firms in 2018 and 2019 failed, with traders blaming the high price of 50 million rupees. No auction was held last year.
Srinivasan said Jharkhand officials were now considering "ways to modify the bid price" for the blocks.
NO OTHER OPTION
Jharkhand's Department of Women, Child Development and Social Security said it ensured children received schooling from home during the pandemic with lessons broadcast on loudspeakers, and district offices were informed of human trafficking risks.
In Mansadi village in Giridih, community leader Anasiah Hembrom said school attendance and literacy rates had improved in recent years, but COVID-19 had resulted in more children and returning migrant workers picking mica to earn a living.
Some returnees have found work under a rural government job scheme, but demand has far outstripped supply and issues such as delayed payments mean many people have dropped out, he said.
"Mica promises guaranteed income at the end of a day's work," he said by phone, while noting that the price of mica from traders had last year more than halved to 5 rupees a kg.
Meanwhile, people are continuing to die in the mines.
Giridih police recorded two mica mine accidents in 2020 – in March and November – that resulted in seven deaths. In both cases, they did not find the bodies but recorded the deaths based on testimonies of villagers and visits to the mica mines.
For campaigners, the solution is clear: regulate the trade.
"The number of people mining mica has increased," said Om Prakash, director at Kailash Satyarthi Children's Foundation, which works with Jharkhand state to end child labour in mines.
"That is why it is important that people get the permission to mine legally, since it is the only livelihood option."
Related stories:
With new data, India plans to fight child labour in mica mines
In search of sparkle: is corporate inaction on mica condemning Indian children to death?
Tech companies reliant on mica despite child labour fears – campaigners
(Reporting by Roli Srivastava @Rolionaroll; Editing by Kieran Guilbert and Belinda Goldsmith. Please credit the Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers the lives of people around the world who struggle to live freely or fairly. Visit http://news.trust.org)
Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.
