EXCLUSIVE-POLL: New York City transport seen as safest in world for women

by Lisa Anderson | https://twitter.com/LisaAndersonNYC | Thomson Reuters Foundation
Wednesday, 29 October 2014 00:01 GMT

A woman uses a Metropolitan Transit Authority (MTA) card to enter the NY subway system at the Times Square station in New York on December 19, 2012. REUTERS/Andrew Burton

Image Caption and Rights Information

NYC transport considered safest but about 34 percent of women still say they've been verbally harassed on city's buses and trains

By Lisa Anderson

NEW YORK, Oct 29 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - Twenty-five years ago women were scared to ride on New York's dirty, dimly lit subway but a Thomson Reuters Foundation survey on Wednesday showed the city's public transport is now ranked by women as among the safest in some of the world's largest cities.

With clean, well-lit subways and buses humming with record numbers of users, New York City was rated as having the safest transport system for women compared to 15 of the world's largest capitals.

But although the city with its prolific yellow taxis and 24-hour subway system was seen as safe to travel at night and authorities fast to crack down on offences, three out of every 10 women said they had been verbally abused on buses and trains.

Women in New York, however, praised the city's transport.

"I was born and raised in New York City. I've never had any problems riding the subway. I've witnessed many things on trains, like (people) dancing and singing, but I've never seen anyone getting hurt," said Nicole, 26, a magazine worker who preferred not to give her last name.

"New York is a safe place ... security has definitely improved over the years. Just today I took the train and I saw cops at almost every station."

It wasn't always this way.

About 25 years ago, graffiti-covered subway cars became global symbols of New York's descent into crime and decay and the city of about 8.4 million people, beleaguered by crime, was widely considered unsafe, particularly for women.

That point was brutally underscored in April 1989, when a young female investment banker was raped, savagely beaten and left to die while running in Central Park.

She survived and became known as the Central Park Jogger, an iconic figure for the fear that plagued a city where people no longer felt safe walking in the park even during the day.


Due to a range of measures, from greater deployment of police on the streets and in the transit system to more aggressive community policing and a clamp-down on littering and turnstile jumping, the city began to see a marked reduction in crime in the 1990s that continues today.

People began returning to the city and neighbourhoods gentrified, driving up the number of people using public transport again which helped make buses and trains safer.

Now equipped with a growing network of CCTV security cameras on streets and transit lines, along with interactive Help Point communications kiosks, New York City is often lauded as the safest large city in the United States.

Figures released by the Metropolitan Transit Authority (MTA) show that as of March this year, annual subway ridership was 1.7 billion, the highest in 60 years.

Nearly eight million people daily use the buses, subways and commuter rails that traverse the MTA's 5,000 square mile (13,000 sq km) service area.

The survey of over 6,550 women and gender and city planning experts by pollster YouGov and the Thomson Reuters Foundation found New York was seen as having the safest transport for women, followed by Tokyo and Beijing.

The worst three cities for women were Bogota in Colombia, Mexico City and Lima in Peru, all Latin American capitals.

New York ranked well when women were asked about their overall perception of safety, about travelling at night, confidence in other passengers coming to their aid if needed and the rate of physical harassment on buses and trains.

But the city didn't fare as well, coming 11th, when women were asked if they had been verbally harassed while on buses and trains with 34 percent saying this had happened to them.

(For all poll stories go to http://poll2014.trust.org; Reporting by Lisa Anderson, Additional reporting by Maria Caspani, Editing by Belinda Goldsmith)

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.