U.S. judge rules Haitians cannot sue U.N. for cholera epidemic

by Reuters
Sunday, 11 January 2015 09:15 GMT

Velune Noel, 24, lies with her cholera-infected 12-month-old son Peterson Sharmont on a cot at a Samaritan's Purse cholera treatment center in the Cite Soleil neighborhood of Port-au-Prince January 8, 2011. REUTERS/Allison Shelley

Image Caption and Rights Information

Outbreak has killed more than 8,600 people and infected over 707,000 since October 2010

By David Ingram

NEW YORK, Jan 10 (Reuters) - Thousands of Haitians killed or sickened by a cholera epidemic that they blame on U.N. peacekeepers cannot sue the United Nations in a U.S. court because the U.N. has legal immunity that only it can waive, a judge has ruled.

In a decision late on Friday, Judge J. Paul Oetken of U.S. District Court in Manhattan dismissed a lawsuit filed by human rights lawyers seeking compensation for the cholera victims.

A lawyer for the plaintiffs said they would appeal the ruling.

The outbreak has killed more than 8,600 people and infected over 707,000 since October 2010, according to the U.N.

Oetken wrote that the U.N.'s ability to block lawsuits was established by a 1946 international convention and was made clear again in a 2010 ruling from a U.S. appeals court in a case of alleged sex discrimination.

"The U.N. is immune from suit unless it expressly waives its immunity," he wrote.

The U.N. did not expressly waive immunity for the Haitians and has not accepted responsibility for the outbreak, although it has tried to raise money for a cholera elimination campaign.

The plaintiffs plan to appeal Oetken's ruling and show that their case is different from the 2010 case, said one of their lawyers, Brian Concannon, executive director of the Boston-based Institute for Justice & Democracy in Haiti.

"We are disappointed in the ruling but not discouraged, and we have always assumed that this case was going to go to the appeals court," Concannon said in a phone interview on Saturday.

Concannon said the U.N. was not entitled to immunity under the 1946 convention because it has failed to establish any kind of settlement process for the cholera victims, as required by the same convention.

U.N. spokeswoman Vannina Maestracci said the organization welcomed Friday's decision and was in the process of reviewing it further. "Our focus in Haiti remains on our commitment to eliminating cholera in Haiti," she said.

U.N. peacekeepers from Nepal likely caused the cholera outbreak when they were stationed near a major river and discharged raw sewage, according to the plaintiffs and a 2011 report from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Cholera, which had not been documented in Haiti in almost 100 years prior to the outbreak, is an infection that causes severe diarrhea that can lead to dehydration and death, and is caused by poor sanitation.

The case is Delama Georges, et al, v. United Nations, et al, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, No. 1:13-cv-7146.

(Reporting by David Ingram and Louis Charbonneau; Editing by Andrew Hay)

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.