Top mobile company Telefonica Brasil found guilty of slave labor

by Fabio Teixeira | @ffctt | Thomson Reuters Foundation
Wednesday, 31 July 2019 21:27 GMT

ARCHIVE PHOTO: A logo at the Brazilian mobile operator Telefonica office, that is no longer in operation, is seen in Sao Paulo, Brazil December 21, 2017. REUTERS/Leonardo Benassatto

Image Caption and Rights Information

The company and its contractors will be fined R$200,000 ($53,167), but also risk being added to a 'dirty list' of companies found guilty of slave labor

By Fabio Teixeira

RIO DE JANEIRO, July 31 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - Leading mobile company Telefonica Brasil and three firms in its supply chain have been found guilty of engaging in slave labor, authorities said on Wednesday.

A panel of labor judges in Espirito Santo state ruled that Telefonica, publicly traded as Vivo in Brazil, was culpable after workers toiled in slavery-like conditions during the building of a cellphone tower in 2014.

The decision supports the idea that companies be held responsible for labor abuses within their supply chain, even when not directly involved in perpetrating them, prosecutors and campaigners said.

"This was a joint conviction of all the members of the supply chain," said Valerio Heringer, Espirito Santo's top labor prosecutor.

"(Labor laws) cannot be forgotten by any firm in a supply chain," Heringer told Thomson Reuters Foundation. "The omission by one company impacts all the others."

The company and its contractors will be fined R$200,000 ($53,167), but also risk being added to a "dirty list" of companies found guilty of slave labor by labor courts.

The list is set to be published for the first time later this year, but prosecutors would not confirm whether Vivo would be added.

"Telefonica informs that it does not condone any illegal work practices," Vivo said in a statement, adding that it would appeal the decision.

Prosecutors said Vivo hired BR Towers, now part of American Tower, to rent a site in Espirito Santo for a cellphone tower, which then contracted Bimetal Industria Metalurgica to plan it. Bimetal subcontracted Norte Amazonia Construçoes to build it.

Eleven laborers were lured for the job from Maranhao, one of Brazil's poorest states, working long hours for a month without adequate rest or bathroom or sleeping facilities, while receiving no pay.

Their employer held their working papers even after the job was done, leaving the workers "in a miserable state, abandoned on the place they were working on, unable to return to their homes," wrote lead prosecutor Antonio Carlos Soares.

The case pre-dates American Tower's acquisition of BR Towers, a spokesman for the company said, adding the company's policy was to not comment on ongoing litigation.

Thomson Reuters Foundation was unable to reach representatives from Bimetal and Norte Amazonia.

In the last quarter, Telefonica reportedly held just over 32% of the mobile market share, posting profits of about R$1,485 billion ($395 million).

Slavery in Brazil is defined as forced labor, but also includes debt bondage, degrading work conditions, long hours that pose a health risk or work that violates human dignity.

At an unrelated event on Tuesday, Brazil's right-wing president Jair Bolsonaro, who swept into office on a populist campaign targeting the opposition's corruption and economic ineptitude, criticized labor laws.

Bolsonaro said Brazil's definition of slave labor "terrorized" employers.

But Caio Magri of Instituto Ethos, a non-profit that promotes sustainable practices by companies, responded that the Brazilian legislation constituted "a principle, a virtue that Brazilian society has created." ($1 = 3.7617 reais) (Reporting by Fabio Teixeira; Editing by Chris Michaud. Please credit Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers humanitarian news, women's and LGBT+ rights, human trafficking, property rights, and climate change. Visit

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.