Poland debates abortion rights curbs, coronavirus limits protests

by Reuters
Wednesday, 15 April 2020 12:30 GMT

ARCHIVE PHOTO: A woman walks with an umbrella as she take part in a rally marking the first anniversary of the “Black Protest” against plans of changing the abortion law in Warsaw, Poland October 3, 2017. The text reads "My choice". REUTERS/Kacper Pempel

Image Caption and Rights Information

The draft legislation would ban abortion if prenatal tests show serious, irreversible damage to the foetus

By Anna Koper and Anna Wlodarczak-Semczuk

WARSAW, April 15 (Reuters) - Polish lawmakers are to debate a proposal to tighten already restrictive abortion rules on Wednesday, while rights activists protested on social media as coronavirus limits public gatherings.

Abortion rights are a contentious issue in Poland, one of Europe's most devout nations, with the nationalist ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party keen to burnish its conservative credentials despite considerable public opposition to further restrictions.

Proposed as a citizens' initiative, the draft legislation would ban abortion if prenatal tests show serious, irreversible damage to the foetus, one of the few instances in which the procedure is allowed in Poland. Others are incest, rape and risks to maternal health.

PiS, a party that campaigns on introducing more religious values into public life, has signalled some reluctance to back the bill in parliament, which it controls, ahead of a presidential election on May 10.

The issue poses a dilemma for PiS, which had previously retreated from proposals to nearly ban abortion after a massive public outcry, because it could galvanise voters on either side of the divide.

By Wednesday, about 700,000 people had signed an online petition to the government to oppose the proposal.

Campaigners also say the PiS would face renewed criticism if it pushed through legislation when restrictions on public life because of the coronavirus pandemic prohibit large-scale demonstrations.

"Citizens' initiatives are often controversial," Deputy Prime Minister Jacek Sasin told private radio Zet. "We will approach this in a responsible way."

Deputies are due to debate the issue late on Wednesday.

Several other citizens' bills are also on the agenda on Wednesday, highlighting a growing presence of conservative and far-right voices in public debate.

One, introduced by far-right activists, would ban the restitution of pre-World War Two Jewish property in Poland in cases when no heirs are alive and would impose jail terms on anyone taking action to satisfy such claims.

Poland is among very few nations in Europe not to have introduced legislation since the collapse of communism to resolve Jewish claims after the Holocaust.

A hunting lobby is also seeking lawmakers' approval to allow children to participate in hunts, banned under Polish law, and another proposal aims to curb sex education in schools.

"So many absurd, inhumane laws are to be approved by the Polish parliament," Agnieszka Holland, a Polish film director and frequent PiS critic, said on Twitter.


Despite the restrictions, some women, standing apart and wearing face masks, protested on Tuesday in Krakow, while in Warsaw some drivers stuck "Women's Strike" protest banners in their car windows.

Underscoring deep-seated support for further restrictions on the right in Poland, President Andrzej Duda told a Catholic news outlet Niedziela that he would sign further curbs into law.

"I believe that killing disabled children is simply murder," Duda, a PiS ally, was quoted as saying.

Opinion polls show Duda winning the May 10 election, although the ballot is clouded in uncertainty because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

PiS is seeking to hold the ballot via post rather than polling booths but a legislative proposal on the issue might clear parliament only days before the election date, leaving little time to organise.

The opposition has said the vote should be postponed because the election campaign has been curtailed by the pandemic, accusing Duda of taking advantage of his position to continue campaigning.

Rights activists in Poland say the pandemic has also curbed women's access to abortion abroad because of travel restrictions throughout Europe.

Many women terminate pregnancies in Germany, Slovakia and further away, in cases when it would be illegal in Poland or when hospitals refuse to perform an abortion that would technically be allowed under Polish rules.

Andrzej Rychard, a sociologist, said a vote for new abortion rules would likely undermine unity within PiS and its conservative ruling alliance, already strained by internal debates over whether the presidential vote should be delayed.

"It would remind people that they can mobilise and protest," Rychard said. "And that could shake up the ruling alliance." (Writing by Justyna Pawlak; Editing by Janet Lawrence)

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.