Our award-winning reporting has moved

Context provides news and analysis on three of the world’s most critical issues:

climate change, the impact of technology on society, and inclusive economies.

Part of: Coronavirus and surveillance
Back to package

EU criticised over surveillance aid in nations where privacy at risk

by Umberto Bacchi | @UmbertoBacchi | Thomson Reuters Foundation
Wednesday, 11 November 2020 01:01 GMT

FILE PHOTO: European Union flags flutter outside the European Commission headquarters in Brussels, Belgium August 21, 2020. REUTERS/Yves Herman/File Photo

Image Caption and Rights Information

European Union aid money might be helping non-member states to spy on their citizen, Privacy International warns

LONDON, Nov 11 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - European Union aid has been used to pay for surveillance equipment and training in countries with inadequate safeguards against excessive state snooping, rights groups said on Wednesday, calling for an end to the "unacceptable" practice.

From training Algerian police on social media monitoring to equipping Niger with phone-tracking tools, the EU has helped numerous nations boost their surveillance capacity in recent years, a report by London-based Privacy International (PI) said.

Despite that, the bloc has no effective controls to ensure its aid is not being used to infringe privacy and other rights in recipient countries, a dozen NGOs said in a letter to the European Commission, urging it to address the issue.

"European governments... must ensure they are not providing the tools of repression to governments around the world," the 12 European and African civil society groups wrote.

Niger was allocated 11.5 million euros ($13 million) in EU funds two years ago to buy surveillance drones, cameras and software to bolster migration controls, said the PI report, which was based on EU documents obtained by the group.

The money also covered the purchase of an IMSI catcher, a tool that allows for covert cellphone tracking, which critics say is overly invasive.

"(Niger) has no laws that regulate the use of this kind of intrusive equipment," the NGOs wrote, saying there was little to deter authorities from using the equipment for purposes other than border surveillance.

It was not clear whether Niger had already acquired the equipment, which EU documents said aimed to help the country in the fight against human-trafficking and illegal migration.

Niger's presidential office and the EU Commission did not immediately reply to a request for comment.


PI's report said EU agencies have also been training authorities across the Balkans, the Middle East and North Africa in "controversial phone and internet surveillance techniques".

Courses delivered over the past few years included teaching Algerian officers how to use fake accounts to gather information on social media and instructing Moroccan agents on how to use software to extract mobile phone data, the report said.

Other initiatives that caused concern included funding a wiretap system in Bosnia and a biometric identification system in Ivory Coast that would accelerate the repatriation of migrants from Europe, it added.

"Instead of helping people who face daily threats from unaccountable surveillance agencies, including activists, journalists, and people just looking for better lives, this 'aid' risks doing the very opposite," said PI advocacy director Edin Omanovic.

The 12 NGOs called on the EU to carry out adequate risk assessment and due diligence processes before providing surveillance support, and to set up a fund to promote privacy and data protection rights aboard.

"The EU should be a promoter of rights, not an enabler of governments to undermine them," read the letter signed, among others by the African Freedom of Expression Exchange, an umbrella group, and Athens-based Human Rights 360.


Face for sale: Leaks and lawsuits blight Russia facial recognition 

Mexico's Senate approves digital violence law to stem 'revenge porn' 

Unfair surveillance'? Online exam software sparks global student revolt

($1 = 0.8458 euros)

(Reporting by Umberto Bacchi @UmbertoBacchi; Editing by Helen Popper. Please credit the Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers the lives of people around the world who struggle to live freely or fairly. Visit http://news.trust.org)

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.