Jewellery brands urged to do more to fight gold, diamond mining abuses

by Kim Harrisberg | @KimHarrisberg | Thomson Reuters Foundation
Tuesday, 24 November 2020 18:31 GMT

ARCHIVE PHOTO: A small-scale miner shows the gold he and his colleagues have found in one day on a small hill overlooking grasslands located around 200 km (125 miles) south-west of the Mongolian capital city Ulan Bator in this April 4, 2012 REUTERS/David Gray

Image Caption and Rights Information

Survey finds few major jewellery brands have taken concrete action to protect rights during COVID-19 pandemic

By Kim Harrisberg

JOHANNESBURG, Nov 24 (Thomson Reuters Foundation) - As jewellery sales get a pre-Christmas boost, consumers were warned on Tuesday that major brands are still not doing enough to combat human rights and environmental abuses in their gold and diamond supply chains.

In a survey of 15 major jewellery companies, Human Rights Watch found few had taken concrete steps to protect workers' rights or assess the impact of COVID-19 as the pandemic fuels labour abuses in mines around the world, a report showed.

The advocacy group did, however, find improvements since it conducted the same survey two years ago.

"Many jewellery companies have made progress ... but consumers still don't have adequate assurances that their jewellery comes free of human rights abuses," said Juliane Kippenberg, associate child rights director at Human Rights Watch.

"The COVID-19 pandemic demands even more vigilance from jewellery companies to identify and respond to human rights abuses," Kippenberg said in a statement.

According to the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, jewellery companies are obliged to monitor and correct human and environmental rights abuse in their supply chains.

The 15 companies surveyed, which generate more than $40 billion in annual revenue, included big brands such as Tiffany & Co and Pandora A/S, both of which were rated "strong" for their efforts on ethical sourcing.

Since the COVID-19 crisis began, rights groups have reported a worsening of working conditions for both formal and informal miners.

Some lost their income when mines were closed due to lockdowns, while others were forced to work and live together in cramped conditions - making social distancing impossible, Human Rights Watch said, detailing different abuses around the world.

Citing past investigations, the report spotlighted torture by syndicates controlling illegal gold mines in Venezuela, as well as child labour and mercury poisoning in small-scale gold mining Ghana, Mali, the Philippines, and Tanzania.

'MAINTAIN STANDARDS'

The advocacy group based its ranking on the sourcing practice information submitted by the 15 companies, or on what was publicly available.

Pandora, which got a higher rating than it did two years ago, told the Thomson Reuters Foundation it aimed to use only recycled silver and gold by 2025, and both the Danish firm and Tiffany & Co said they were proud of their progress.

Human Rights Watch's report classified Bulgari, Cartier and Signet Jewelers Limited as "moderate" for their efforts to responsibly source gold and diamonds.

Signet responded by saying it was "dedicated to the continuous improvement in the integrity of the global jewellery supply chain".

Boodles, Chopard and Harry Winston were ranked "fair" though they all got a higher score than in the 2018 report.

While the survey recognised improvements at Indian jewellery maker Tanishq, it was ranked "weak" along with Chow Tai Fook and Germany's Christ.

Tanishq said it did not agree with the ratings in the report, arguing they did not reflect "on-ground issues in the supply chain", while Chow Tai Fook said it appreciated "valuable recommendations to the industry".

The Hong Kong-based firm is investing in blockchain technology for "digital mine-to-consumer records of diamonds", it added.

There was not enough information available to rank Kalyan, Mikimoto, Rolex and TBZ, Human Rights Watch said.

The other brands included in the survey did not immediately reply to a request for comment.

Responding to Tuesday's report, the Responsible Jewellery Council - which sets ethical standards for the jewellery and watch industry - said it was working to address the pandemic's impact on the sector.

"People across the world are impacted in multiple ways by the COVID virus. The jewellery industry is no exception. It is vital to maintain standards in these challenging times," the council said in emailed comments.

Related stories:

Fears rise for illegal South African miners hiding underground in virus lockdown  

Garment workers on front line of Sri Lanka coronavirus outbreak

Africa's miners face new TB threat as pandemic disrupts treatment 

(Reporting by Kim Harrisberg @KimHarrisberg; Editing by Helen Popper. Please credit the Thomson Reuters Foundation, the charitable arm of Thomson Reuters, that covers the lives of people around the world who struggle to live freely or fairly. Visit http://news.trust.org)

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.